Scale & Strategy
his is Scale & Strategy – we tee up the best of business insights, so you can hit non-stop home runs!
Here’s what we got for you today:
- Beyond the Archetype: Rethinking What Makes a Great Founder
Beyond the Archetype: Rethinking What Makes a Great Founder
In early-stage investing, we often say we back companies. But more accurately, we back people — the ones rewriting how the world works. The kind who blend analytical sharpness with engineering instincts, who turn hard-won insights into product, and who can sell a still-invisible future to investors, employees, and users alike.
The bar is high. And while iconic founders are rare, the industry still loves to bucket them into neat patterns. Ask around any startup café and you’ll hear the usual suspects: Stanford CS grads, ex-Google PMs, the Peter Thiel talent tree. These heuristics are comforting. But are they useful?
We were skeptical. So we went looking for signal in the data.
Who Really Builds the Breakout Consumer Companies?
We analyzed over 100 U.S.-based consumer unicorns — startups that raised at least one valuation at $1B+ according to PitchBook. We focused exclusively on companies selling to end users: consumer apps, marketplaces, and prosumer platforms. No B2B, no crypto, no edge cases.
What we found wasn’t a blueprint, but it was directional. Some myths held up. Others didn’t. Across categories, experience levels, geographies, and cofounder dynamics, patterns emerged that challenged the “ideal founder” narrative we’ve grown used to. Here’s what stood out.
1. Two’s Company, Not a Rule
The solo founder is a myth with great PR. In reality, most breakout consumer companies are built by teams — on average, 2.2 cofounders. And not all of them started on day one. Some joined after product-market fit, others after Series A.
Interestingly, founder composition varies by category. One-third of top marketplaces had solo founders (e.g. Weee!, Rover), while solo success in consumer apps was much rarer — fewer than 1 in 5. The structure that works best often reflects the complexity of the category.
2. The “Goldilocks” Experience Curve
Experience matters — but too much or too little can slow momentum. The sweet spot? Founders with 7–9 years of experience. Not fresh grads. Not 20-year veterans. People with enough reps to know how things should work, but still hungry enough to rethink everything.
Consumer app founders skewed slightly older, prosumer founders slightly younger. But across the board, this “in-between” experience level gave founders both recruiting leverage and earned insight — two currencies that compound early.
3. Geography Still Matters (Sorry, Nomads)
Despite remote work and global hiring, consumer unicorns still cluster in cultural hubs. Over two-thirds of breakout companies were headquartered in California (54%) or New York (14%). Austin showed signs of life (6%), while Miami — much hyped, less delivered — barely registered.
Why? Consumer companies often require cultural intuition, network density, and a proximity to top creative and technical talent. The shift to remote hasn’t erased those dynamics — at least not yet.
4. Stanford Signal: Strong, but Not Singular
Some stereotypes persist for a reason. Stanford showed up frequently in our analysis, especially among consumer app founders, where nearly 1 in 3 companies had at least one founder from The Farm.
But broaden the lens, and the dominance fades. While 47% of companies had at least one Stanford or Ivy League founder, over half didn’t. And many of the most compelling businesses were built by founders from outside the “pedigree pipeline.”
5. Big Tech: Helpful, Not Definitive
We often hear that ex-Google, ex-Meta, or ex-Amazon founders have an unfair advantage. In reality, it depends on the category.
In consumer apps, ~40% of cofounders came from Big Tech. But in marketplaces and prosumer platforms? That number dropped to under 20%. The halo around these logos is real — but it doesn’t always correlate with breakout outcomes. Google, notably, was the one outlier with consistent overperformance.
6. Serial Founders: Overrepresented for a Reason
Over half the companies we studied had at least one repeat founder — especially in more operationally complex categories like marketplaces, where prior scar tissue seems to translate directly into speed and conviction.
These weren’t always “successful” past ventures by traditional metrics. But the learnings translated. In a world where time to PMF is everything, experience shipping something (anything) matters more than a perfect resume.
7. Technical Founders: Less Common Than You Think
In the B2B world, technical cofounders are often table stakes. But consumer is different. Just 40% of the companies we studied had a technical cofounder — and that number drops significantly in marketplaces and prosumer platforms.
Why? Because technical execution can often be hired. But cultural taste, storytelling, and customer intuition — especially in early-stage consumer — are much harder to outsource.
8. Related Founders: Risky, but Real
Investors often flinch at backing couples, siblings, or parent-child teams. But ~4% of consumer unicorns had exactly that — and they’re not small names: Canva, Eventbrite, Houzz.
Relationship dynamics can add friction, but they can also add trust. What matters most is alignment, clarity of roles, and the shared stamina to survive the inevitable chaos of scaling something new.
Rethinking What “Great” Looks Like
We didn’t set out to debunk founder archetypes for sport — we did it to better recognize greatness when we see it. And the data is clear: there is no single formula. Category, context, and chemistry all matter.
So the next time someone tells you the perfect founder looks like [insert cliché here], remember: if greatness came with a checklist, everyone would be doing it.
We’ll keep looking beyond the heuristics — and betting on the people bold enough to change the game.
Was this email forwarded to you?
That’s it for today and as always It would mean the world to us if you help us grow and share this newsletter with other operators.
Our mission is to help as many business operators as possible, and we would love for you to help us with that mission!
