​

Scale & Strategy

This is Scale & Strategy, your color commentator coming to you live, ringside in the business arena.

Here’s what we got for you today:

• What to Do When an Investor Passes on Your Startup

What to Do When an Investor Passes on Your Startup

Hearing “no” from an investor—especially after pouring your heart into a pitch—can be a gut punch.

You’ve spent weeks refining your deck, tightening your story, anticipating objections, and de-risking every possible concern. You walk into that meeting confident you’ve covered your bases.

Then comes the reply:

It’s frustrating. Disheartening. Even infuriating.

But now you have a decision to make. You’ve got a few options:

Option 1: Fire off a response explaining why they’re wrong.​
​Option 2: Say nothing and never speak to them again.​
​Option 3: Turn the moment into a strategic advantage.

Why Option 1 Doesn’t Work

When someone passes on your startup, it’s tempting to correct them. To explain what they missed. To defend your model. To argue that your opportunity is massive and that their logic is flawed.

But here's the problem: that rarely lands well.

Founders who are quick to argue can come across as defensive or uncoachable. And coachability is a critical trait investors look for. It doesn’t mean blindly following every piece of feedback. It means being open to alternative perspectives, curious about other approaches, and willing to adapt when the data says you should.

So when you respond by saying “you don’t understand this market” or “you’re going to regret passing,” even if you’re right, you’re not winning points. You’re closing the door.

And there’s a second issue:
The reason in the rejection email? It might not be the full story.

Sometimes investors point to the most benign reason they’re comfortable sharing. The real reason might be:

• They just backed a similar company.
• They’re over-allocated in the category.
• They’re unsure you’re the right founder for this market.
• They didn’t feel conviction—and can’t afford to make a “maybe” bet right now.

In other words, arguing with their stated reason is often irrelevant—because it may not even be the reason.

Rather than trying to turn a “no” into a “yes” (which rarely works), it’s usually more productive to expand your top-of-funnel. More intros, more meetings, more reps.

But that doesn’t mean a rejection is worthless.

Here’s What to Do Instead

When an investor gives you a specific reason for passing—like “sales cycle too long”—you’ve actually been handed a gift: an opening to learn.

You can follow up with a brief, respectful reply that turns their comment into insight:

• “Appreciate you reviewing our deck. Out of curiosity—what sales cycle duration would you expect to see in this category?”
• “Are there startups you’ve seen with similar customer profiles that managed to shorten their cycle?”
• “What kind of metrics or progress would make this more compelling at a future stage?”

These questions do two things:

1. They demonstrate you’re receptive to feedback and eager to learn.
2. They help you gather benchmarks that can inform future pitches—and possibly shape your roadmap.

They also keep the conversation alive in a positive, low-pressure way.

Keep the Door Open

Just because an investor passed today doesn’t mean they’ll pass forever. Businesses evolve. Metrics improve. Teams get sharper.

One of the simplest ways to maintain the relationship is to ask:

It’s a light touch. It doesn’t ask for anything. And it gives them a front-row seat if your startup begins to take off.

Many founders who eventually raised from top-tier funds did so after sending consistent, thoughtful updates for 6–12 months post-rejection.

Final Thought

Rejection is part of the game—but it doesn’t have to be the end of the conversation.

The startup world is smaller than it seems. Investors talk. Reputations stick.

When you handle rejection with grace, curiosity, and professionalism, you’re not just increasing your chances with that one investor—you’re building the kind of reputation that makes other investors want to work with you.

And in this game, that matters just as much as your pitch.

Was this email forwarded to you?

That’s it for today and as always It would mean the world to us if you help us grow and share this newsletter with other operators.

Our mission is to help as many business operators as possible, and we would love for you to help us with that mission!